I had a great time here and the pizza was super satisfying. The crust had a nice chew and crisp edge, and the cheese tasted fresh and melty. The tomato sauce was flavorful but not overpowering. The place had a casual vibe and our server was quick and friendly. Would definitely order again.

Sottocasa continues to be our favorite neighborhood pizza spot. Incredibly friendly with pies that do not disappoint. Chewy, flavorful crusts with nice beers. Our favorites are the 4 Formaggi and the Laura. The marscapone offers a nice nutty, sweet flavor that lightens the pie and the other cheeses balance it out along with the meat. Truly delightful pie.

Great Italian pizza and salads... other items as well. Relaxing environment. Good vibes. The owners are AMAZING humans who actually CARE about delivering quality food and service. AND, they have beautiful Italian accents to boot!! GO!

Great Italian food. It was my first time trying authentic Italian food and it was better than I thought. The good focuses on the natural flavor of ingredients, so you will taste what you see. In overall, it seems like not much of seasoning was used, which I liked. Not greasy, fresh and light flavor, so even I could finish one pizza by myself. You will not get tired of pizza. The dough was also really good. Chewy but not hard. If you are used to New York pizza style or salty food with lot of seasonings, this pizza could be bland to you, but I actually liked this kinds of style. I got Verdure with Soppierssata added. I really enjoyed it and recommend it!

The pies were absolutely amazing!!!! One of the best pizza spots in Harlem. The Tartufata is mouthwatering. I'm ordering it again! The Margherita is delicious but it's your classic. Friendly and efficient service. Great ambiance and diverse crowd. They have a great wine selection if you're into wine.

I've dined at the Brooklyn, and now I love it here too! These are excellent wood-fired pizzas, and I've both dined here and gotten takeout. I'm very slowly working my through the menu and I've yet to find a pizza that's a dud. I do prefer the red sauce, and love the pizza with eggplant (verdure and parmigiana) and the anchovies (napoli).

Really great pizzas in Harlem! Straight off the bat, I will say my one miff was that no matter how empty the restaurant, they will make you wait at the bar until your full party has arrived. I was a little frustrated by it, and I could hear the frustration from the next two parties who came after me, when they asked, "Everyone's here, can we sit now?" If it's a full restaurant, I completely understand, but only 5 tables were occupied, and they have their expanded space in the back, so I'm not sure why to have people wait at the bar when no one's going to order a drink there until their whole party comes. If anything, I'd order a drink at the table so it's not much carrying back and forth. Otherwise, the pizzas are great! They're a reasonable personal pie size, cut into quarter slices. I ordered the Bufalotta and it was so, so delicious!! I'm still dreaming about it: arugula, prosciutto, buffalo mozz, and basil! I also shared the Popeye, and that was pretty good, too, for a vegetarian option! The restaurant is very cute and I would definitely come here again, I would just wait for my party outside before coming in altogether. I know, I know, a first world problem, lol, but it really makes a difference on the experience.

This is a great little gem in Harlem serving up Neapolitan style pizza. Service is very quick and the interior is beautiful. Makes for an intimate night with friends or a romantic date. They have gluten free options too!

Small and simple restaurant with wonderful Italian pizzas, thin-crust, very delicious. But before even starting that, consider the sangria (particularly if the weather is hot outside), and consider finishing the feast with some dessert, eg the panna cotta or the coconut icecream or the lemon icecream with prosecco. Delicous.